:: Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe ::
I can’t even remember the specifics of what was happening the day this fudge came on the scene. Around here that’s saying a lot! I do know it was a day everyone was kind of needing a little pick-me-up. Not so much down in the dumps, but desperate for something indulgent. We don’t do that usually and I didn’t have many options on hand. I don’t know the specifics of how everyone’s woes were lamented, or what those pleading eyes looked like as I decided to brave the bare pantry shelves looking for some sort of means to wow them with panache.
This recipe doesn’t call for marshmallows or sweetened condensed milk! yay! Because I didn’t have any. May I just add that everyone not only survived the day but I was a total HERO. 🙂
Of course it’s a family favorite now – maybe because of how I wow’d them – but more likely because of the day we were all having and how these little gems were exactly what we needed. A little something special. A little indulgence. We all remember how it made us feel. That’s a huge connection with recipes in a family! I still remember how I felt sitting around the table with my siblings as a child having some of the dishes my mother would make. And that’s exactly what I wanted to do for my family on that day – not feed them fudge, but build a memory.
It’s reminiscent of how my grandmother may have made fudge. It takes a tad longer, but as with many things, it’s so very worth the wait. This fudge is far superior to any other fudge I’ve made and it’s tucked safely in my arsenal.
Ingredients
- 2 cups brown sugar
- 2 cups white sugar
- 1 cup milk
- 1 1/2 cups peanut butter (I used creamy)
- 1 Tbsp butter
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
Instructions
- In large saucepan bring brown and white sugar and milk to a boil
- Stir in peanut butter
- Reduce heat to medium
- Bring back to a boil stirring constantly
- Remove from heat when mixture is at soft ball stage (when dripped into cold water it forms a ball)
- Stir butter and vanilla into mixture stirring vigorously until fudge hardens (this takes 10 min or so)
- Pour fudge onto waxed paper lined cutting board
- Cut with knife when cooled
If you’re having any doubts about taking the extra few minutes for this fudge than some of the quicker versions, let me push you over the edge: It will put you in peanut butter heaven I can guarantee!
Do you have any other fudge flavors that are a favorite? Any unique fudges you can share with us? We’d love to learn from you!
I am so happy you posted this. I was just talking about bringing fudge to a party this weekend, but didn’t have a good recipe.
Robin (Masshole Mommy) recently posted…The Africa Tram at the San Diego Zoo Safari Park
Oh a party! How fun!!! I’d love to hear if you find it to be a crowd pleaser – if you make it, Robin!
yum!! I love fudge and add in peanut butter? You can’t go wrong with that.
Absolutely Amanda – peanut butter wins at everything! hahaha
These look so delicious! It’s hard to pass up anything peanut butter!
They have the look of homemade caramels which makes them even more enticing.
Brandy M. recently posted…Kindergarten Readiness Checklist
Peanut butter always gets me Brandy – you’re right – they do sort of resemble caramels!
I haven’t made peanut butter fudge in ages. This looks so darn good!
Definitely fits nicely into the ‘so darn good’ category, Angela! Here’s to a batch real soon 🙂
I absolutely love peanut butter fudge, but I can’t remember the last time I made any. Now I’m going to have to make some soon! Thanks for the recipe.
You’re welcome Pam! I don’t think of making fudge often – of course talking about it is making me think of making it now! hahaha
I love peanut butter. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe. It is now on my to make list.
Great Ann! I am a fellow peanut butter fan!!! If you make it I’d love to hear feedback!
Oh my goodness, I am drooling. I so wish I was not on a diet! Yummy!
Mama to 5 BLessings recently posted…Groovy Girls Dolls Along With Totally Tentastic (Giveaway)
Wipe your chin — this would be a perfect reward for reaching a goal:) I mean, not the whole batch but…. 😀
Yum, fudge and peanut butter are some of my favorite treats. I would love to try this recipe! Thank you!
Amy Desrosiers recently posted…Pesto Parmesan Grilled Steak and Spinach Salad
Peanut butter has some serious power, huh Amy?? I’d love to hear feedback if you do try it!
This sounds excellent. I might just have to make this for Father’s Day!!
Jennifer Soltys recently posted…Surrender the Booty Pirate’s Booty Giveaway
Great idea Jennifer! Thanks for stopping by!
I love fudge. I will have to try this and make it for my grandmother
Debi@ The Spring Mount 6 Pack recently posted…Some of The Top Must See Things To Do In Philadelphia
Debi – I’d LOVE to hear her reaction if you make it – Hope you enjoy!
I’m such a sucker for good fudge! This sounds like an amazing recipe I must try one day very soon 🙂
Dawn Lopez recently posted…Make Your Own First Aid Kit with Summer Healthy Essentials with Johnson & Johnson & Giveaway #FIFA
Aren’t we all suckers, Dawn??? hahaha! that’s funny – I must admit it was pretty cool pouring it out onto the cutting board!
Oh my! This is killing me! It looks amazing! :It reminds me of a caramel kind of treat! The peanut butter must taste incredible. Gotta try this! 🙂
Nancy Lustri (StyleDecor) recently posted…A Perfect At-Home Gel Manicure!
I have one 19 yr old sugar fiend in particular in the house Nancy and she is on my case all the time for more batches… it’s unreal! Good stuff = let us know if you try it!
Pinning this to make on the next rainy weekend! Brings back great child hood memories.
Thanks so much Racquel – we are so appreciative of you sharing it! Here’s to a rainy weekend soon in your future! 🙂
Mmm, I remember eating these as a little girl! Thanks for sharing this recipe!
Brett Martin recently posted…Things I don’t leave home without
Absolutely Brett – I have been cooking interchangeably with almond butter specifically and have never run into trouble! Let us know if you try it!!!
Oh my yummy! Do you think this would work with all nut butters?
Emily recently posted…Why Didn’t You Tell Me!?!? (Light Bladder Leakage)
That looks amazing! I have a weakness for peanut butter and sweets.
tammileetips recently posted…Outback Steakhouse Moonshine BBQ
Me too- Tammilee… peanut butter has some magical powers!
Oh yum!
Janice recently posted…Easy Peach Turnovers
Exactly, Janice! 🙂 Thanks for stopping by!
Oh boy, does homemade fudge ever sound good about now! This looks fantastic!
Liz Mays recently posted…TGI Fridays Serves Up Free Food Tastes #SummerofFridays
It really is, Liz – I was actually glad I didn’t have the ingredients on hand for a quick fudge!
That fudge looks so good! I want a piece! There is nothing like home made fudge.
StacieinAtlanta recently posted…@MicrosoftStore Opening in Atlanta ~ Gifts for Grads #SmartHappensHere #ad
Hmmm, a friends mom used to make this, so this recipe is very nostalgic to me. I need to try and make it myself!!
Tammi @ My Organized Chaos recently posted…Strawberry Jello Pie
YUM! I have always wanted to try to make my own fudge! This looks easy too, great recipe!
kristin recently posted…Starting Out – Our Ordinary Life
If you’ve never made it you are in for a huge treat, Kristin!
Wow that is so simple to make! My hubby and oldest son will love it!
valmg @ From Val’s Kitchen recently posted…5 Goodies Perfect For Gluten-Free Dads!
You’ll have to let us know if you make it – and if they enjoy!
This looks really good. I love fudge but have never attempted to make my own. Yummy!
Stefani Tolson recently posted…Tomato Basil Tart Recipe
Sounds great, but was wondering if you use an electric mixer or do it all by hand. I have arthritis in my hands and not sure I could stir it for ten minutes. Thanks.
Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe
http://slam-news.com/2016/04/27/old-fashioned-peanut-butter-fudge-recipe/